Mr Magic LLC

Mr Magic LLC Your number one store in the greater Cleveland area for all things trading cards, board games, video games, miniature / roll play games and much more.

We not only sell, but also buy used or unwanted trading cards and video games.

The Mr. Magic hotlist is officially LIVE at the Columbus Card Show! Come visit us at the XXL Show all weekend long for b...
05/22/2026

The Mr. Magic hotlist is officially LIVE at the Columbus Card Show! Come visit us at the XXL Show all weekend long for bulk drop offs, great deals, and cash offers on your cards.

We’re actively buying everything from bulk to high-end singles, collections, and sealed product. Whether you’re clearing out extra cards or moving premium inventory, we want to take a look at it.

Bring your Pokémon, MTG, sports, and more — we’re paying aggressively all weekend.

Stop by the booth, check out the hotlist, and turn your cards into cash or store credit!

🔥 Friday Hotlist is LIVE! 🔥The newest Mr. Magic Hotlist is here with FINAL cash or store credit prices on select cards. ...
05/22/2026

🔥 Friday Hotlist is LIVE! 🔥

The newest Mr. Magic Hotlist is here with FINAL cash or store credit prices on select cards. No promos, no trades—just straight payouts on Hotlist items.

Looking to sell? Now’s the time! We are ALWAYS buying Pokémon, MTG, and more.

⏳ This Hotlist is valid through May 28th at close.

Stop in today:
5204 Detroit Rd, Sheffield, OH 44035

Prices are subject to change at any time

🔥 Friday Hotlist is LIVE! 🔥First off — THANK YOU to everyone who stopped by and saw us at Collect-A-Con last weekend. We...
05/15/2026

🔥 Friday Hotlist is LIVE! 🔥

First off — THANK YOU to everyone who stopped by and saw us at Collect-A-Con last weekend. We loved meeting new faces, catching up with longtime customers, and seeing so much support from our local community. Events like these remind us how lucky we are to do what we do. ❤️

Now onto business…

This week’s Hotlist is LIVE with updated FINAL cash or store credit prices on select cards. No trades, no promos — just straight payouts on Hotlist items.

💵 Bring your cards in and get paid CASH on the spot.
📈 We are ALWAYS buying collections, singles, sealed product, and high-end cards — even outside of Hotlist items.

Stop into the shop:
📍 5204 Detroit Rd, Sheffield, OH 44035

⏳ This Hotlist is valid through Thursday at close, with updated Hotlist pricing dropping again Friday at open.
Prices are subject to change.

Thanks again for an incredible Collect-A-Con weekend — now let’s keep the momentum rolling. 🔥

🧹 SPRING CLEANING SALE EXTENDED AT MR MAGIC 🧹You asked… we listened! Our Spring Cleaning Sale was such a hit in April th...
05/13/2026

🧹 SPRING CLEANING SALE EXTENDED AT MR MAGIC 🧹

You asked… we listened! Our Spring Cleaning Sale was such a hit in April that we’re extending it through the entire month of May! That means more time to turn your old cards into serious cash or even MORE value in store credit 👀

💰 Trade-In Bonus
Get 20% EXTRA on your trade-ins — we pay up to 80% value on cards, slabs, and sealed product!

📦 BULK RATES

POKÉMON
• $25/K Common/Uncommon
• $50/K Rares/Holo Rares
• $40/K Reverse Holo
• $0.70 ea EX/V
• $1 ea IR/TG/Full Art

MAGIC
• $7/K Common/Uncommon
• $20/K Foil
• $0.10 ea Rare

🔥 Clean out those long boxes and turn bulk into cash. This deal runs through May 31st, so don’t wait.

📍 5204 Detroit Rd, Sheffield, OH 44035
💸 Stop in and get paid today.

⚠️ Bulk must be Near Mint & English only.
⚠️ No trade-in bonus on bulk.

We’re officially set up at Collect-A-Con Cleveland and ready to buy, sell, and trade all weekend long! Stop by the Mr. M...
05/09/2026

We’re officially set up at Collect-A-Con Cleveland and ready to buy, sell, and trade all weekend long! Stop by the Mr. Magic booth to check out our huge selection of Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, sealed product, singles, accessories, and more.

Have cards or collections you’re looking to sell? Bring them by! We’re paying strong cash and store credit offers all weekend.

Come say hi, make some deals, and see what treasures you can find at the show!

If you can’t make it to the event, our store is always open at 5204 Detroit Rd, Sheffield, OH 44035

🔥 Friday Hotlist is LIVE! 🔥This week’s Hotlist is here with FINAL cash or store credit prices on select cards. No trades...
05/08/2026

🔥 Friday Hotlist is LIVE! 🔥

This week’s Hotlist is here with FINAL cash or store credit prices on select cards. No trades or promos — just straight payouts on Hotlist items.

💵 Bring your cards in and get paid CASH on the spot!

🚨 This weekend we’ll also be at Collect-A-Con at the Huntington Center ALL WEEKEND long!
Come find us right in front of the room — we’re paying CASH for collections, singles, sealed, and bringing out the HEAT all weekend long. 🔥

Whether you’re at the show or local to the shop, come see us:
📍 5204 Detroit Rd, Sheffield, OH 44035

⏳ Hotlist valid through Sunday at close.
We are ALWAYS buying, so don’t wait!

Prices are subject to change.

Something big is happening at Mr. Magic… and we still can’t say what it is 👀Our Games Workshop sale is so good, we can’t...
05/01/2026

Something big is happening at Mr. Magic… and we still can’t say what it is 👀

Our Games Workshop sale is so good, we can’t post details. Our prices are already below MSRP—and this goes even further.

Call or stop in to find out.

📍 5204 Detroit Rd, Sheffield, OH 44035

🔥 Friday Hotlist is LIVE! 🔥Our newest Hotlist is here with FINAL cash or store credit prices on select cards. No trades ...
05/01/2026

🔥 Friday Hotlist is LIVE! 🔥

Our newest Hotlist is here with FINAL cash or store credit prices on select cards. No trades or promos—just straight payouts on Hotlist items.

Bring your cards in and get paid on the spot!

⏳ This Hotlist is valid through May 7th at close.

We are ALWAYS buying, so don’t wait!

Stop in today:
5204 Detroit Rd, Sheffield, OH 44035

Prices are subject to change

🔥 Friday Hotlist is LIVE! 🔥Our latest Hotlist is here with FINAL cash or store credit prices on select cards. No trades ...
04/24/2026

🔥 Friday Hotlist is LIVE! 🔥

Our latest Hotlist is here with FINAL cash or store credit prices on select cards. No trades or promos—just straight payouts on Hotlist items.

Bring your cards in and get paid on the spot!

⏳ This Hotlist is valid through April 30th at close.

We are ALWAYS buying, so now’s the time to sell!

Stop in today:
5204 Detroit Rd, Sheffield, OH 44035

Address

5204 Detroit Road
Sheffield, OH
44035

Opening Hours

Monday 12pm - 8pm
Tuesday 12pm - 8pm
Wednesday 12pm - 8pm
Thursday 12pm - 8pm
Friday 12pm - 9pm
Saturday 12pm - 9pm
Sunday 12pm - 8pm

Telephone

(440) 695-1049

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mr Magic LLC posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Mr Magic LLC:

Shortcuts

Share

Category