One More Time

One More Time The One More Time stores are Columbus' premiere consignment & resale shops which offer clothing, accessories, furniture and home decor.

Our low prices on high quality merchandise make one more time stores a popular destination for shoppers! We make it easy to part with your less-loved clothes and accessories and turn them into cash. And once you clear out your closets, we can help you fill it back up with great new-to-you items at low prices. one more time provides two ways for you to sell your clothes. We can either buy your item

s outright or place them on consignment. Please browse our website for information and then feel free to give us a call or come visit us. Come on in and browse our wide selection of high quality merchandise priced at a fraction of the original cost.

All new, all waiting for you in store or online at onemoretime.com 📲 Swipe to see the latest! 🤎
06/20/2026

All new, all waiting for you in store or online at onemoretime.com 📲 Swipe to see the latest! 🤎

Spotlight Pick ♥️A classic flat never goes out of style! This beautiful pair of rich burgundy Tuckernuck flats is brand ...
06/20/2026

Spotlight Pick ♥️

A classic flat never goes out of style! This beautiful pair of rich burgundy Tuckernuck flats is brand new with the original box and ready for its next owner!

👠 Women’s Size 8
💲 $45.99

Find them online at onemoretime.com or shop in-store at One More Time, 1521 W. 5th Ave. in Columbus, OH 📍

06/20/2026

A big thank you to everyone who joined us for yesterday’s Live! 💛And one more reminder: Today is the last day we’re accepting Summer consignments! Stay tuned for exciting things coming soon! 🍂✨

Proof that a simple color palette can make a big impact ✨Mint green, cream, and soft yellow came together so well in the...
06/19/2026

Proof that a simple color palette can make a big impact ✨

Mint green, cream, and soft yellow came together so well in these looks. Which one would have made it into your closet?

06/19/2026
06/19/2026

All Conference Chic pieces Chris showed in today’s live linked below!!! 👇 😱
First come, first serve! ☀️✨

Luxury look, consignment price! ✨Today’s Item of the Day is this gorgeous brown mock croc Brahmin bag, the perfect acces...
06/19/2026

Luxury look, consignment price! ✨

Today’s Item of the Day is this gorgeous brown mock croc Brahmin bag, the perfect accessory to elevate everything from everyday outfits to special occasions 🤎

👜 Brahmin
💲115.99

Shop online at onemoretime.com or stop by One More Time at 1521 W. 5th Ave. in Columbus, OH to see it in person!

06/19/2026

🎥 LIVE TODAY at 3 PM 🎥 Join Chris for our Conference Chic Live! 💼✨ She’s featuring outfits perfect for conferences, work events, business casual settings, presentations, and any occasion where you want to look your best and feel confident!

Join us LIVE tomorrow at 3 PM with Chris for our Conference Chic Live 💼✨ Blazers and trousers to polished tops, dresses,...
06/18/2026

Join us LIVE tomorrow at 3 PM with Chris for our Conference Chic Live 💼✨ Blazers and trousers to polished tops, dresses, professional pieces & more!! Whether you’re attending an event, refreshing your work wardrobe, or just love a put-together look, this live is packed with stylish finds you’ll want to claim. 👀

Set your reminder now and join us tomorrow at 3 PM for some serious outfit inspiration! 💖

06/18/2026

Looking for your next favorite outfit??? We’ve got you covered! 🛍️✨

Whether you stop by the store or shop from the comfort of your couch on our website, there are plenty of ways to browse all the amazing secondhand finds waiting for you!!!

Come see us in person or online… we can’t wait to help you find something you’ll love 💕

Address

1521 W 5th Avenue
Columbus, OH
43212

Opening Hours

Tuesday 11am - 6pm
Wednesday 11am - 6pm
Thursday 11am - 6pm
Friday 11am - 6pm
Saturday 11am - 6pm

Telephone

+16144860031

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when One More Time posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to One More Time:

Shortcuts

Share

Category