But First, We Play

But First, We Play But First, We Play! is a charming small toy shop in the Village of Wappingers Falls, NY.

NeeDoh Jelly Squishes & Gumdrops are here!🪼 Gumdrops are $7.99 each and Jelly Squishes are $8.99 each. Limit 2 NeeDohs p...
06/17/2026

NeeDoh Jelly Squishes & Gumdrops are here!🪼
Gumdrops are $7.99 each and Jelly Squishes are $8.99 each. Limit 2 NeeDohs per person, 4 per family (must be present). No holds and no online orders. We open at 10:30AM.

Rumi is coming back to But First, We Play! Saturday, August 15th 🎤 It’s gonna be Golden!!Join us at But First, We Play! ...
06/07/2026

Rumi is coming back to But First, We Play! Saturday, August 15th 🎤 It’s gonna be Golden!!
Join us at But First, We Play! Toy Shop for a super fun Rumi singalong and bracelet party at 1PM.
Registration is required. Time slots are available every 20 minutes and are a suggested arrival time to make sure everyone gets time with Rumi.
Please register at ButFirstWePlay.com under “events” and follow the checkout process to complete registration.

05/31/2026

Lava Squish N’ Flows are SO much fun! Made by the same company as NeeDoh, these little squishies feature glow-in-the-dark lava globs that move with each squish! Available in store or online at ButFirstWePlay.com

Just in! Gumdrop NeeDohs have dropped here at But First, We Play! Toy Shop. Visit us at 2695 W Main St in Wappingers Fal...
05/31/2026

Just in! Gumdrop NeeDohs have dropped here at But First, We Play! Toy Shop. Visit us at 2695 W Main St in Wappingers Falls, NY.
Limit 1 per person/family. We open at 11AM on Sunday, 5/31/26.

Ms. Rachel is coming to But First, We Play! Toy Shop. Stay tuned for dates!
05/30/2026

Ms. Rachel is coming to But First, We Play! Toy Shop. Stay tuned for dates!

More mystery dumplings have arrived! 🥟 These dumplings are the standard 4” size and are $9.99 each. We are currently sol...
05/30/2026

More mystery dumplings have arrived! 🥟 These dumplings are the standard 4” size and are $9.99 each. We are currently sold out of the mini dumplings, however we did order more.
3 per customer, please. No holds.
These dumplings have been going fast!

05/24/2026

Rumi came to But First, We Play! Toy Shop 👏

05/24/2026

Address

2695 W Main Street
Wappingers Falls, NY
12590

Opening Hours

Wednesday 10:30am - 5:30pm
Thursday 10:30am - 5:30pm
Friday 10:30am - 5:30pm
Saturday 10:30am - 5:30pm
Sunday 11am - 4pm

Telephone

+18456619966

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when But First, We Play posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category