06/16/2026
Trying to Build Something Beautiful in a Town That Needs It
I’m reading all of these comments, and I really appreciate
everyone sharing their thoughts. I may not be able to answer each one individually, but I’m grateful for the conversation this opened up.
Applegarth was never just a little shop to me. It was a place with its own feeling — rocks, plants, minerals, gifts, conversation, curiosity, and that quiet sense of magic that is hard to explain until you walk into a space like that.
Seeing that some of you still remember it, miss it, or would like to see something like it return means more to me than I can say.
I wanted to add a little more detail for everyone who has commented or asked about the possibility of reopening Applegarth Apothecary, Rock & Gift Shop.
The desire is absolutely still there.
We have been working on cleaning up and preparing a small property outside of town, on the way to Bailey Creek, with the hope of creating a cozy little version of Applegarth again. Something small, peaceful, beautiful, and unique. A place with rocks, minerals, gifts, plants, and that same quiet sense of magic the original shop had.
The difficulty is that reopening is not as simple as just putting things on shelves and opening the door.
We would love to reopen inside Soda Springs, or even in Lava, but the reality is that retail space is expensive, and affordable small storefronts are very hard to find. Rent, utilities, insurance, and overhead can quickly make a small shop impossible before it even begins.
And I will be honest: this is part of a larger frustration I have had for a long time.
I love this area, but it often feels like our city and county have not made it easy for small businesses, gift shops, specialty stores, art spaces, plant shops, rock shops, or unique tourist-friendly places to survive here. I am not saying that to attack any one person or any current official. But over the years, decisions have been made — politically, economically, and structurally — that seem to have made it much harder for small, independent businesses to open and thrive.
Just look at Main Street.
So many spaces are empty, aging, neglected, or far too expensive for the kind of small local businesses that could actually bring life back into town. Meanwhile, opening something small often feels harder than it should be unless you are a large corporation with enough capital, legal support, and influence to push through the process.
That is discouraging.
When I first opened Applegarth, I was hoping to create a place where people passing through Soda Springs would stop, wander, enjoy themselves, buy something beautiful, and remember the town as more than just somewhere they drove through.
And it did that.
We received five-star reviews again and again on TripAdvisor, and Applegarth was often listed among the top things to do when visiting Soda Springs. That meant a lot to me, but it also said something about the need for more unique places here. People want reasons to stop. They want beauty. They want discovery. They want something memorable.
That is what I was trying to build then, and it is still what I am trying to build now.
So that leaves us trying to create something more modest in the county, in a small building on private property with easy public access. But that also comes with restrictions.
Because it would be considered a home-based business, there are rules about signage, traffic, hours of operation, permits, inspections, and how often we can be open. There may also be requirements involving accessibility and construction changes to make the building easier and safer for people to enter.
There is also another very real part of this that I want to be honest about. I am still caregiving for my mother. I made a promise to my father, and to my own conscience, that I would take care of her to the end. That promise matters to me deeply. So whatever Applegarth becomes, it has to be something I can build around that responsibility, not something that pulls me away from it.
None of this is impossible, but it does make the question more complicated.
I know a lot of people will say, “Just do it anyway and ask forgiveness later.” I understand that feeling, believe me. But that is not really a workable path for us. If we are going to do this, we need to do it correctly, legally, and in a way that does not create future problems.
That is the challenge.
We are trying to figure out how to build something magical while still working within very real limitations.
I don’t say this to complain. I say it because I want people to understand the constraints we are working with. This is why I am trying to determine whether there is enough real local interest before investing more money, time, permits, inspections, construction, and personal energy into the project.
I am trying to do something positive. I am trying to create something beautiful, local, unusual, and welcoming. Something that gives people another reason to stop here, shop here, and remember this place.
But I am also up against very real obstacles.
That is why I wrote the original post. Not to stir up drama, but to ask honestly whether there is enough community support to make the next steps worth taking.
If you have ideas, advice, experience with small business permitting, affordable retail space, accessibility solutions, tourism, signage, county regulations, or creative ways to make something like this work, I would genuinely love to hear them.
And to everyone who has encouraged this idea, commented, shared memories, or said they would support Applegarth returning — thank you. Truly.
Applegarth may still be able to return.
It may just have to return in a smaller, quieter, more carefully planned form than before.