The Toffee Peddler

The Toffee Peddler Gourmet Handmade Toffee by Theresa Gourmet Handmade Toffee, Cheesecakes and other baked goods by Theresa

We had our cake competition today in Del Webb SCGCC...I took 2nd🙄with my frosted animal cookie cheesecake...my German sw...
03/09/2026

We had our cake competition today in Del Webb SCGCC...I took 2nd🙄with my frosted animal cookie cheesecake...my German sweet chocolate cake didn't even place. Oh well🤷‍♀️

I took first in the pie contest in our Del Webb Spruce Creek Golf & Country Club community! Lemon filling in a macadamia...
03/09/2026

I took first in the pie contest in our Del Webb Spruce Creek Golf & Country Club community! Lemon filling in a macadamia nut crust with a blackberry coulis swirled in!

Simple and decadent ... and one of my favorites! Nutella cheesecake!
01/09/2026

Simple and decadent ... and one of my favorites! Nutella cheesecake!

I've been busy have not posted in awhile but had a couple cakes go out for Thanksgiving. Here's one...Dutch apple...stuf...
11/26/2025

I've been busy have not posted in awhile but had a couple cakes go out for Thanksgiving. Here's one...Dutch apple...stuffed filling with apple and crumble on top. For a very special friend.

NOT your ordinary lemon cheesecake...what makes it special is the Limoncello! What makes it extra special is making it f...
11/16/2025

NOT your ordinary lemon cheesecake...what makes it special is the Limoncello! What makes it extra special is making it for someone you love! Happy very late birthday Judy!

All finished! Waiting for customer pickup!
09/20/2025

All finished! Waiting for customer pickup!

Stay tuned...hot out of the oven. I'll decorate it tomorrow! 🍋
09/18/2025

Stay tuned...hot out of the oven. I'll decorate it tomorrow! 🍋

07/10/2025

Sami Hansen at AspenOak was kind enough to put 15 bags of my pretzel toffee at her shop in Elkhart Lake! Thanks Sami!
It will be there for a very limited time then I'll be heading back to Florida!

White chocolate raspberry 😋
05/22/2025

White chocolate raspberry 😋

In the kitchen today making Baklava with the best teacher ever! I swear my father sent this man to be in my life. He's w...
05/22/2025

In the kitchen today making Baklava with the best teacher ever! I swear my father sent this man to be in my life. He's witty, smart, funny, loving and caring just like my Dad was! Everyone that meets him loves him. Thanks Papa Bear Barry🥰

Getting into the Christmas Spirit!Sugar cookie crust vanilla base cheesecake covered in white chocolate.
12/18/2024

Getting into the Christmas Spirit!
Sugar cookie crust vanilla base cheesecake covered in white chocolate.

Address

Sheboygan, WI
53081

Telephone

+19202079728

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Toffee Peddler posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Toffee Peddler:

Shortcuts

Share

Category