04/24/2026
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/18uho2zfjL/
Santa Anna was captured on April 22nd and brought before Sam Houston, who lay wounded on a mattress underneath the boughs of an oak tree in the Texas camp. John Forbes' audited pension application in the Republic Claims Files describes what happened:
"I put my hand on his arm to rouse him. He raised himself on his elbow and looked up. The prisoner immediately addressed him, telling him who he was and surrendering himself to him, a prisoner of war.
General Houston looked at him intensely but made no reply, turning to me, requested me to proceed to the guard fire and bring...before him a young man who was reported to be the private secretary of Santa Anna and could talk English fluently. I did so, and on my return found the prisoner seated quietly in a chair beside the General's mattress.
The young man, on seeing the prisoner, assured Genl. Houston that the prisoner then before him was truly Genl. Santa Anna. General Houston, wanting additional evidence, sent me again to the guard fire to bring Genl. Almonte before him. In bringing down Genl. Almonte, I met Genl. Th. J. Rusk and Lieut. Zavalla...They accompanied me with Genl. Almonte to where Genl. Houston was, when the prisoner was fully recognized and identified."
"The conqueror of the Napoleon of the West is born to no common destiny," Santa Anna said, "and can afford to be generous to the vanquished."
"You should have thought about that at the Alamo," Houston countered.
Santa Anna tried to justify his actions at the Alamo by saying that it was taken by storm which allowed everyone inside to be killed. Houston was unmoved, so Santa Anna claimed he was only following orders from his government.
"You ARE the government!" Houston snapped. And he continued by saying that no grounds whatsoever excused the slaughter of Fannin and his men at Goliad. He was in no mood for hearing any of Santa Anna's hogwash, and several accounts describe Santa Anna as losing his nerve under Houston's cold resolve.
Sam Houston was the only one standing between Santa Anna and a rope, a bullet, or a blade. Everyone wanted him killed. Though a persistent myth still circulates about Sam sparing Santa Anna's life out of Masonic respect, he instead made a careful, pragmatic decision.
There were thousands of Mexican troops still in the field under other Mexican generals, and Houston did not know where they were. Had those troops pressed the attack, Houston's men would have been wiped out and history would have unfolded very differently. Sparing Santa Anna allowed him to be used as a diplomatic bargaining chip to get Filisola and Urrea to back off.
But Houston had a second reason, a moral reason, for not killing Santa Anna. He said (paraphrasing) "We're better than that." He said that to be respected around the world, Texas had to show that its values were different than those of other upstart countries. Effectively saying, that's the way banana republics change power –by killing whoever was in charge before the new people took over. And we're not doing that. We're better than that.
"Alive Santa Anna may be of some use to us," Houston said, "dead, he's just another dead Mexican."
TCU's Dr. Gregg Cantrell observed, "Houston could point to the battlefield that was littered with the bodies of 600 dead Mexican soldiers, one more wasn't going to make a difference even if it was the President of Mexico."
(Please "Like" and "Share")
