Pennywise Mystic

Pennywise Mystic Upscale Consignments & Overstocks for Women & Men. Two floors of clothing, purses, shoes, accessories

The best of today's designers and name brand clothing and accessories for men and women at a fraction of the price! Open seven days a week and we accept all credit cards and Apple Pay!

Katie's picks of the week! Mure Grand sweater, fish necklace, Gucci kitten heels, Missoni poncho, and Manual Canovas dre...
06/25/2026

Katie's picks of the week! Mure Grand sweater, fish necklace, Gucci kitten heels, Missoni poncho, and Manual Canovas dress (she already claimed the two-piece set she's wearing!)

It's a gorgeous day...for finding our fourth gift card of anniversary week! Tag us when you've got it!
06/25/2026

It's a gorgeous day...for finding our fourth gift card of anniversary week! Tag us when you've got it!

We highly suggest you stop into one of our favorite spots in Mystic when you go look for gift card number three today. T...
06/24/2026

We highly suggest you stop into one of our favorite spots in Mystic when you go look for gift card number three today. Tag us when it's in your hand!

Time for Tuesday's gift card clue! Today's gift card is somewhere cozy on this rainy day. Tag us when you find it!
06/23/2026

Time for Tuesday's gift card clue! Today's gift card is somewhere cozy on this rainy day. Tag us when you find it!

Day 1 of our anniversary gift card hunt is here!! We didn't have to go far for this one (or even cross the busy street)....
06/22/2026

Day 1 of our anniversary gift card hunt is here!! We didn't have to go far for this one (or even cross the busy street). Tag us when you find it!

In honor of our 38th anniversary we're turning Mystic into a treasure hunt! Starting Monday, June 22 a Pennywise gift ca...
06/21/2026

In honor of our 38th anniversary we're turning Mystic into a treasure hunt! Starting Monday, June 22 a Pennywise gift card will be hidden in town every day until our birthday on Saturday, June 27. Follow along for clues as we reveal a new location daily and be sure to tag us if you find one! 🎁

Alyssa's picks of the week! Anthropologie skirt, Sarah Stewart purse, House of Harlow sandals, Robert Graham shirt and E...
06/20/2026

Alyssa's picks of the week! Anthropologie skirt, Sarah Stewart purse, House of Harlow sandals, Robert Graham shirt and Escada jeans 🛍️

Bianca's picks of the week from Vans, Jacquie the Label, Reformation and Kate Spade!
06/19/2026

Bianca's picks of the week from Vans, Jacquie the Label, Reformation and Kate Spade!

06/19/2026

Fr part 2

06/19/2026

FP new arrivals!

Address

22 Greenmanville Avenue
Mystic, CT
06355

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 5pm
Tuesday 10am - 5pm
Wednesday 10am - 5pm
Thursday 10am - 5pm
Friday 10am - 5pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm
Sunday 10am - 5pm

Telephone

+18605729232

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Pennywise Mystic posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category