Mystery to Me

Mystery to Me We're a general bookstore with a specific name. Buy local! We can order ANY book! A general bookstore with a very specific name.... we specialize in mystery.
(247)

Father’s Day = 🔜 (Sunday 6/21, don’t worry it snuck up on us too)
06/17/2026

Father’s Day = 🔜 (Sunday 6/21, don’t worry it snuck up on us too)

What’s the MTM staff currently reading, you ask?! 🗡️Hannah: The Reimagining of Thornwood House and The Heirs 🥚Elizabeth:...
06/16/2026

What’s the MTM staff currently reading, you ask?!

🗡️Hannah: The Reimagining of Thornwood House and The Heirs
🥚Elizabeth: Cleaner and Other Women
💀Zekky: Gideon the Ninth
🌙 Hilary: The Children

Is it Wednesday? Yes. Did these books technically come out on Tuesday? Also yes. But they are still new and exciting eve...
06/10/2026

Is it Wednesday? Yes. Did these books technically come out on Tuesday? Also yes. But they are still new and exciting even a day late 💜

It’s officially SUMMER READING SEASON 😎⛱️ – but are you still looking for that perfect beach read? Maybe wishing you cou...
06/05/2026

It’s officially SUMMER READING SEASON 😎⛱️ – but are you still looking for that perfect beach read? Maybe wishing you could talk to a friendly local book fairy, someone who would listen to exactly what you want to read and then press a book into your hands and say “ok now THIS is the one”? WELL YOU’RE IN LUCK  🎉

Come down to the bookstore on Friday, June 12th for a round of Booksish Matchmaking – you’ll fill out a survey & tell us what you’re looking for in your perfect summer read, we’ll hand it off to a pro, and voila! We’ll match you with a summer read that’s right for you. Drinks, snacks, and bookish fun start at 6 PM – see you soon!!

What’s that smell? Smells like…SUMMER!We’re so excited to have these yummy scented perfume rollers from Wisconsin’s very...
06/03/2026

What’s that smell? Smells like…SUMMER!
We’re so excited to have these yummy scented perfume rollers from Wisconsin’s very own 🌼💜☀️ Come take a whiff and tell us which is your favorite!

Happy June!!! We have a great bunch of new releases out this week.
06/02/2026

Happy June!!! We have a great bunch of new releases out this week.

We are so exciting to be hosting Wisconsin Women’s Voices: A Two Part Poetry Reading! Part one is June 4th at 6pm. Each...
05/27/2026

We are so exciting to be hosting Wisconsin Women’s Voices: A Two Part Poetry Reading! Part one is June 4th at 6pm. Each night will feature four poets from across Wisconsin. We are so excited to have all these wonderful poets in the room together and hear from them all! Please join us on June 4th and keep your eye out for Part 2 on July 9th! RSVP on our website!

Some big names with new releases today, including Ruta Sepetys’s adult debut!
05/26/2026

Some big names with new releases today, including Ruta Sepetys’s adult debut!

If you’re looking for ways to keep the kids using their brains this summer, we have plenty of activity books for all age...
05/24/2026

If you’re looking for ways to keep the kids using their brains this summer, we have plenty of activity books for all ages!

Ahhhhh the smell of new books on a Tuesday 💜
05/19/2026

Ahhhhh the smell of new books on a Tuesday 💜

Address

1863 Monroe Street
Madison, WI
53711

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10am - 6pm
Wednesday 10am - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 6pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm
Sunday 10am - 4pm

Telephone

+6082839332

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Mystery to Me posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Mystery to Me:

Shortcuts

Share

Category