The Mystical Mermaid

The Mystical Mermaid Gift shop with family swimwear, clothing, snorkel gear, souvenirs,crystals, tarot cards and swim tails. We have hand-dipped incense, sage, stones, and crystals.

We are a unique family owned business with a mermaid theme and a mystical twist! The Mystical Mermaid is a unique kind of gift store/gallery. We have a great selection of mermaid items ,tank tops, jewelry and local lobster trap art. Many of our gifts and artwork are handmade by local artists and we have a nice selection of fine art as well! Come see our Uniqueness!!

05/27/2026

If you're looking for retail displays or fixtures, stop by and see what we have. Everything must go!!

05/07/2026

Stop by the Mystical Mermaid in Islamorada. Everything is now 40% off. There's still tons left to chose from. (Prices will not go lower.) No shipping unless previously agreed.

04/26/2026

After over 12 1/2 years The Mystical Mermaid is closing its doors. Join us Monday as we start our 30% off sale. Grab those mermaid tails before stock runs out!!! We will be liquidating everything, including displays!

Look for the mermaid and get 20% off everything in the store!
04/14/2026

Look for the mermaid and get 20% off everything in the store!

03/17/2026

The app won't let me edit but we will be closed on Sunday and Monday now.

Valentines Day...Handmade glass pendants, and earrings!! Great gifts that last!
01/14/2026

Valentines Day...Handmade glass pendants, and earrings!! Great gifts that last!

We have unique handmade glass ornaments that will last a lifetime!!!!
12/05/2025

We have unique handmade glass ornaments that will last a lifetime!!!!

Stop at the Mystical Mermaid in Islamorada for unique glass gifts!! Add a silver plated or sterling chain to complete y...
12/05/2025

Stop at the Mystical Mermaid in Islamorada for unique glass gifts!! Add a silver plated or sterling chain to complete your gift!!

Jellyfish art piece or ornament. 4"x6".
11/26/2025

Jellyfish art piece or ornament. 4"x6".

Glass Christmas tree ornament. $34.99 plus tax and shipping
10/29/2025

Glass Christmas tree ornament. $34.99 plus tax and shipping

Address

82693 Overseas Highway
Islamorada, FL
33036

Opening Hours

Tuesday 10am - 4pm
Wednesday 10am - 4pm
Thursday 10am - 4pm
Friday 10am - 4pm
Saturday 10am - 4pm
Sunday 10am - 2pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Mystical Mermaid posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Mystical Mermaid:

Shortcuts

Share

Category