That Geek Gallery

That Geek Gallery That Geek Gallery is an online store. We sell all sorts of geeky stuff! This page is to promote and bring together geeks for fun & giveaways! That Geek Gallery is an online Amazon store that also participates in local and regional marketplaces at various conventions.

We sell all sorts of geeky collectibles and odds and ends with a focus on trading card games like Pokemon and Magic the Gathering. We also are a contracted third party seller! Have a collectible you wish to sell? Contact us for a free appraisal and fee estimation for us to sell your item. Guaranteed to beat any rate of other third party sellers!

Operating as usual

09/15/2021

Hey geeks! lots of items going up soon on Etsy! Stay tuned!

Hey Geeks!It’s been way to long so I want to update you as quick as possible but please, bear with me here. To start, fr...
05/16/2020

Hey Geeks!

It’s been way to long so I want to update you as quick as possible but please, bear with me here. To start, from February of last year to this time last year I was very sick. I spent a bit over 2 weeks in the hospital and at least another month bed bound at home. I have congestive heart failure and more than one lung disease and they can snowball out of control quickly and my broken arm started that snowball in a hurry. Thankfully by the end of May I started to rebound. We kept the store running slow so I could focus on recovery. In September we began to slowly start ramping up the store in prep for peak holiday shopping, our favorite time. All was going well until October 8th, 2019 when my cousin, my best friend, part of my heart and soul that will never return, passed away. To say I was devastated is an understatement. In that moment If not for knowing I had David who I could never leave, and Aiden who is still growing up and needs me, and yes of course my other family but I’m trying to keep it short, I don’t think I could have found a way to keep going on. It’s been 7 months and I’m just now starting to MAYBE get some normalcy. My first thought was, reopen my store. It’d keep me busy, AND it’s something I absolutely love doing. When everything happened in October, I had 3 open orders I refunded all 3. Then I put my store into vacation mode. I learned that setting up vacation mode was a must have after my coma in 2017. When I turn on vacation mode it automatically sends out an email to certain customers, I wrote it years ago it says, in short, “the ownsers of that geek gallery have temporarily shut down their store, likely due to illness/hospitalization or some other serious complication of life. You have been fully refunded and when the store reopens you will be given 15% off anything, we hope to be back soon.” That email went out to those with active orders that hasn’t shipped yet but if you sent a message to us on eBay at all, you got that auto reply. This led to 3 people reporting me and my metrics fell too low. Low metrics plus me taking such a long break led to eBay being less than helpful. Also because I fell below standards when I went into a coma (which I quickly fixed that!) They did give me a probation possibility to get my account back, but it’d be a minimum of 6 months. I’d have to pay my store fee for 6 months without being able to make the money to afford the store fee. So I’m really bummed out. I’m looking into other ways, and I will let you all know as soon as I as I do! I love this store too much to give up that easily!

PS please don’t contact on my behalf. I found another customer support team that is supposedly much better so I’ll try them!

Much Love, Stay Geeky, And stay safe!

Erin Renae Reid

Five lucky customers of ours will get these packages in a few days...
09/06/2018

Five lucky customers of ours will get these packages in a few days...

Hi Geeks!I apologize for the wait! I tried to post this already, but Facebook didn't cooperate. Anyway, #GetGeeky becaus...
06/26/2018

Hi Geeks!

I apologize for the wait! I tried to post this already, but Facebook didn't cooperate.

Anyway, #GetGeeky because we're giving free swag, and giving away a prize valued at $50+!

Here's how you enter. **NOTE: You must have liked our page to enter any of our giveaways. **

Share a recent post, or even better, this one! Message us your address and we will send you a free That Geek Gallery decal pictured below, and 3 other high quality waterproof stickers containing random geekery. Once you get your That Geek Gallery Decal, stick it somewhere it will be seen! Oh, by the way, I mean the one with our Logo, not the random ones! Then post a picture to your Facebook timeline telling us its general location (no need to be specific, we aren't into stalking!) and tag us in it by typing @ThatGeekGallery and clicking our name when it pops up.

We will reply to your post with a random code. On July 25th our newest team member, Aiden, will go live on Facebook and YouTube and choose the winner(s) at random.

Now, I specifically put "winner(s)" because depending on how many participate in this, we may do more than one prize, some might even get a free swag item like a shirt, hat, pen, bag, etc. I know July 25th is a whole month away but since were relying on snail mail we want to be sure everyone gets their stickers!

Like I said the MAIN prize will be worth over $50, but the more people who join, the more chance we will add more prizes, and anything free is good, right?! And while you wait on your stickers and wait for the drawing, shop with us! Tons of new stuff is going up this week! www.eBay.com/str/ThatGeekGallery

You can start...… NOW!

#StayGeeky!

Hey #Geeks!We still plan to do the “Glitch” contest, but  I’m holding off on it for just a bit. However, #GetGeeky becau...
06/25/2018

Hey #Geeks!

We still plan to do the “Glitch” contest, but I’m holding off on it for just a bit. However, #GetGeeky because tomorrow I will be announcing something where our fans can earn themselves some free That Geek Gallery #swag! Plus, depending on how many participate, maybe some some free merch too!

#StayGeeky!

Hi Geeks! #WinterIsComing! Here is just one of MANY newly listed items! We plan to add well over 100 items to our stock ...
06/25/2018
SIGNED GAME OF THRONES BRAN STARK HODOR ISAAC HEMPSTEAD KRISTIAN NAIRN AUTOGRAPH | eBay

Hi Geeks! #WinterIsComing! Here is just one of MANY newly listed items! We plan to add well over 100 items to our stock in the next few days!

#StayGeeky

https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?mpre=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.ebay.com%2Fulk%2Fitm%2F192567015791

David and I have been engaged for almost a year now, and we just bought a house together. Stay GEEKY! Search That Geek Gallery or @ThatGeekGallery. After over 5 months, That Geek Gallery is BACK and here to serve all of your geeky needs! | eBay!

#GetGeeky over some of our celeb/artist pics from Indy PopCon Signed merch will be for sale soon!!#StayGeeky
06/10/2018

#GetGeeky over some of our celeb/artist pics from Indy PopCon Signed merch will be for sale soon!!

#StayGeeky

06/09/2018
That Geek Gallery joins YouTube Star Wars, Funko, Firefly, Walking Dead, Marvel, Gaming merch & more

A bit of a late post but That Geek Gallery has a new team member! Meet Aiden, our Internet Personality, Videographer, Vlogger, and trainee in all things geek! Aiden is Erin and Dave’s nephew! Look for more videos with him!

https://youtu.be/aFjjul0gFCI

That Geek Gallery is joining YouTube! Videos coming soon! Until then: Facebook: www.facebook.com/ThatGeekGallery Twitter: www.twitter.com/ThatGeekGallery Ins...

06/08/2018

Hey geeks! That Geek Gallery is at Indy PopCon this weekend! Watch for Erin Renae Reid and David Good at the Indianapolis Convention Center! #GetGeeky #StayGeeky

Heads up Geeks! A contest is coming your way SOON! This one the gamers will love for sure! Here is a photo with a little...
06/02/2018

Heads up Geeks! A contest is coming your way SOON! This one the gamers will love for sure! Here is a photo with a little hint about the contest. The prize? FIVE comic books. You can choose vintage or newer, and you can also give suggestions on types of comics you prefer such as, DC/Marvel, Spiderman, Spawn, etc. We cant PROMISE you will receive exactly what you ask for but we can promise you will either get vintage or newer comics that you will find interesting and they will be in great condition. Estimated value of the prize is $25-$35! Stay tuned and Stay Geeky!

Ohhh this is something to really #GetGeeky over! l A Star Wars Aayla Secura figure that is signed by the voice actress, ...
05/15/2018
AUTOGRAPHED STAR WARS CLONE WARS AAYLA SECURA SIGNED VOICE ACTRESS JENNIFER HALE | eBay

Ohhh this is something to really #GetGeeky over! l A Star Wars Aayla Secura figure that is signed by the voice actress, Jennifer Hale! We had the pleasure of meeting Jennifer Hale at the 2017 Indiana Comic Con! She was a super friendly person! She is extremely talented and has had so many different roles in stuff from videogames, tv, to straight to video movies! Some of her more well known roles are in Mass Effect I, II, III as the female version of Shepard. Metal Gear Solid, Gears of War, Animated Star Wars, Elder Scrolls online, Dragon Age: Inquisition, DuckTales, animated X-men and recently she even had a live acting role in Showtimes hit TV show, Shameless! Don't miss your chance to get this awesome collectible! If you think a different price is more fair for this item, send us a best offer, you never know what we might accept!

She's truly an amazing talen't! After over 5 months, That Geek Gallery is BACK and here to serve all of your geeky needs! Search That Geek Gallery or @ThatGeekGallery. David and I have been engaged for almost a year now, and we just bought a house together. | eBay!

Good morning again, I have another item for you all to  #GetGeeky over, and it has a bit of a fun fact to go with it. Th...
05/14/2018
NIB VINTAGE STAR WARS LOTT DODD WALKING THRONE TOY TACO BELL PIZZA HUT FREE S&H | eBay

Good morning again, I have another item for you all to #GetGeeky over, and it has a bit of a fun fact to go with it. This is one of those cool star wars fast food promo toys that everyone was going crazy for. They came from Taco Bell, Pizza Hut, and even KFC. This is one of the more rare ones and if you notice, the box says Lot Dodd Walking throne, but the characters name is actually Lott Dod. They added an extra d to the end of the name for some reason. At first I was not sure if I was right about this, but I do use captioning when I watch TV and movies so I often get shown the correct spelling for character names. I checked Wookiepedia to see what they say and here's what I found:

Lott Dod was a Neimoidian male politician who served as the senator of the Trade Federation during the Invasion of Naboo and the Clone Wars

#Oops, looks like someone messed up! I do suppose that Wookiepedia could be wrong, but I doubt the caption and Wookiepedia, and in fact, all of google would be wrong haha. So yep this is a cool piece of memorabilia with a typo on it, those pieces are always fun! Does anyone here have any answers for us? If so, share the post with your take on which one is correct, or you can just comment here if you don't want to share, but definitely drop us a LIKE!

Keep an eye here, especially you Star Wars fans! I won't spam you with a bunch of item links at once, so I will be posting a couple together throughout the day, but make sure you check our other items in our eBay store! If you aren't a Star Wars fan, don't worry! We have plenty of other stuff going up today! Give us a Like, Comment or Share, you will be glad you did... rumor has it there will be another #giveaway soon!
Stay Geeky!
#SmallBiz #StarWars #Misprint #YouHadOneJob!

NIB VINTAGE STAR WARS LOTT DODD WALKING THRONE TOY TACO BELL PIZZA HUT FREE S&H | Toys & Hobbies, Fast Food & Cereal Premiums, Fast Food | eBay!

Good morning! Who's ready to  #GetGeeky? Look at this, remember the Pizza Hut, Taco Bell, and KFC promo toys for Star Wa...
05/14/2018
NIB VINTAGE STAR WARS ANAKIN VIEWER TATOOINE TOY TACO BELL PIZZA HUT FREE S&H!! | eBay

Good morning! Who's ready to #GetGeeky? Look at this, remember the Pizza Hut, Taco Bell, and KFC promo toys for Star Wars Episode I? We're listing sealed, unopened toys from that promo. Almost 20 years old and they are completely untouched! I just LOVE finding stuff like this, even though its not a high value item, its still amazing finding cool little collectibles that have been saved all of these years. Keep an eye here, especially you Star Wars fans! I won't spam you with a bunch of item links at once, so I will be posting a couple together throughout the day, but make sure you check our other items in our eBay store! If you aren't a Star Wars fan, don't worry! We have plenty of other stuff going up today! Give us a Like, Comment or Share, you will be glad you did... rumor has it there will be another #giveaway soon!
Stay Geeky!
#SmallBiz #StarWars

Item: Here we have a new and unopened 1999 Star Wars promo toy that was from Taco Bell, KFC, and Pizza Hut, this is the "Anakin Viewer - Tatooine" toy and it allows you to see a scene from the movie. | eBay!

We're up bright and early to #GetGeeky and show you some of what we're putting up on eBay! Keep an eye here, especially ...
05/14/2018
MINT APPLAUSE STAR WARS DARTH MAUL RESIN FIGURE 61760 RARE COLLECTIBLE UNOPENED | eBay

We're up bright and early to #GetGeeky and show you some of what we're putting up on eBay! Keep an eye here, especially you Star Wars fans! I won't spam you with a bunch of item links at once, so I will be posting a couple together throughout the day, but make sure you check our other items in our eBay store! If you aren't a Star Wars fan, don't worry! We have plenty of other stuff going up today! Give us a Like, Comment or Share, you will be glad you did... rumor has it there will be another #giveaway soon!

Stay Geeky!

#SmallBiz #StarWars

I repeat, this item is UNOPENED and UNTOUCHED! After over 5 months, That Geek Gallery is BACK and here to serve all of your geeky needs! Search That Geek Gallery or @ThatGeekGallery. David and I have been engaged for almost a year now, and we just bought a house together. | eBay!

We ran into some bumps reopening the store, but look for new items on our ebay store in the next 12 hours! In the meanti...
05/04/2018

We ran into some bumps reopening the store, but look for new items on our ebay store in the next 12 hours! In the meantime, is anyone interested in a bulk lot of various editions of Star Wars on VHS and other George Lucas movies? Two are still totally sealed, one is partially sealed and it includes the original Star Wars artwork (see buff, muscled Luke lol). There is also a copy of the Phantom Menace on VCD, in English from Malaysia. There is a whole story behind the VCD formats that came out of Malaysia and other areas. Here are some pics. PM if interested!

Happy Monday Geeks! I know we have been away for awhile, it’s a long story, but the short version is I (Erin) got really...
04/30/2018

Happy Monday Geeks!

I know we have been away for awhile, it’s a long story, but the short version is I (Erin) got really sick in December, and then in March David and I moved into our new home. We’re finally ready to open up shop again though, so stay tuned! There will be new items, new giveaways, and sometime soon our mystery boxes will return! We’re both excited to get started again! Look for posts later today that will show some new stuff we’ve got!!

Hey Geeks!! It’s been a minute, and we are not officially reopened yet but hopefully soon! Still, as always, we’re obtai...
03/31/2018

Hey Geeks!! It’s been a minute, and we are not officially reopened yet but hopefully soon! Still, as always, we’re obtaining what geeky collectibles we can! Recently, we had obtained two Millie Bobby Brown (eleven from stranger things) signed poster/prints. A friend bought one of them today, I’m posting a pic of the other one we have left. If no one is interested we will gladly hang onto it because this baddy comes with a certificate of authenticity that costs a pretty penny to get to begin with. Since these specific prints were very limited and come with its own certificate of authenticity where it’s been entered into an online database, the value will only raise over time, so we really don’t mind holding on to it, especially since Godzilla will release in the near future and she stars in it, but we decided to put it up here and see if anyone is willing to buy it for $200, we will let it go. Right now I would say after either stranger things season 3 or Godzilla releases (whichever happens first) the value on this will be $300-$350. We MAY be willing to come down on price, not a lot but a Little bit. Let me know if interested and feel free to share! We most likely won’t offer this again at this price!

12/03/2017

For personal reasons, the That Geek Gallery store is on hold, tentatively until February 2, 2018 (a date that's fluid at this time).

I know it’s been quiet here lately, which is really unusual for us because the holidays are usually our busiest times, b...
11/25/2017

I know it’s been quiet here lately, which is really unusual for us because the holidays are usually our busiest times, but we’re soon relocating! With much more space means MORE inventory, more room to photograph and list items, and all sorts of good stuff! For Cyber Monday, I will be listing a few new items and offering some deals on current stock, and after we settle in at our new place, we will run some AWESOME giveaways, and begin to list our massive inventory we have amassed, but just don’t have the space to easily access it. We hope everyone is enjoying their holidays! Stay Geeky!

We're thrilled that Bill Simms is happy with his win! For the awesome review, Bill will earn an additional entries to us...
08/22/2017

We're thrilled that Bill Simms is happy with his win! For the awesome review, Bill will earn an additional entries to use any way he wants!simply comment the amount of entries you'd like to use on a future giveaway, and we handle the rest! You don't have to use all 40 at one time, it's up to you!!

Hey everyone , i am so sorry that i have been so late in posting these pictures. Due to some earlier mailing problems and my being in the midst of a move at the time , when i did finally get the comic, i had chose Justice League #1 - 1987 , i was delighted to find That Geek Gallery had also added as a bonus, Justice Legue #2 -1987. Both were in great shape !! Thanks to all involved , they really are a great addition to my collection :)

Address

6538 Cobham Ln
Indianapolis, IN
46237

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when That Geek Gallery posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to That Geek Gallery:

Videos

Nearby shops


Other Collectibles Stores in Indianapolis

Show All

Comments

Do you buy old star wars comics and collectables?
Hey everyone , i am so sorry that i have been so late in posting these pictures. Due to some earlier mailing problems and my being in the midst of a move at the time , when i did finally get the comic, i had chose Justice League #1 - 1987 , i was delighted to find That Geek Gallery had also added as a bonus, Justice Legue #2 -1987. Both were in great shape !! Thanks to all involved , they really are a great addition to my collection :)
Saw your post on Irvington Neighbors and thought you might wanna check us out. Not all geek stuff but old school Nintendo (8-bit) art. We do some festivals, and eBay. But we do have an etsy store that we do pretty well at. Would love to find a place to show off our pieces on a more permanent basis; if possible. Check us out! Thanks!!