Poppin' Tags Thrift Store

11/14/2025

Lets face it, we all like thrifting. Here is something to look for, we have all seen those old VHS tapes at the stores. Are they really worth anything?

Most of the rows of Disney VHS tapes aren’t worth anything. But here is one that breaks the rules, here is a sealed Disney Pixar cars, VHS. It was released only through the Disney movie club, never sold in stores, and represents the final Disney/Pixar film ever printed on VHS before the format died.

Because of that tiny, exclusive run and the nostalgia of it being the last one. Sealed copies have sold for thousands of dollars. And use copies in nice condition/used can bring good money also. So be on the lookout…

11/13/2025

and this is why people go thrift shopping!

Found at Goodwill (and no it wasn’t me🤣) for $4.49. Value: $20k!
This isn't luck. It's one of those once-in-a-lifetime thrift discoveries people talk about for years.
The piece is a Viktor Schreckengost Jazz Bowl, made around 1931, Cowan Pottery, Instantly recognizable to collectors. It was originally designed for Eleanor Roosevelt, and only a few were ever made. Each one is considered a masterpiece of American industrial art.
Just this year, one of these bowls sold for $21,280 at auction. Most people walk right past things like this, but trained eyes know what to look for. That's the thrill of thrifting. You're not just finding used stuff, you're uncovering pieces of history hiding in plain sight!

07/25/2025

Looks like it’s gonna be a busy profitable day today. Went on a pic yesterday, got some nice diecast cars and farm toys. Picked up some old outboard motors and parts, a wood pumpkin seed racer boat, and what I believe is a 1950s Jetra small fiberglass race boat. Come check it out at Poppin Tags Thrift Store tags on hyw 27 south in Hayward WI

06/21/2025

06/21/2025

Bought 250 fishing lures the other day, they are all going in my thrift shop. I easily have about 1200 fishing lures for sale at Poppin Tags Thrift Store in Hayward. I have bass, walleye, panfish and a large selection of musky lures. Easily the largest collection of used fishing lures for sale, in the area, and at friendly prices. Always buying fishing lures, old or new, doesn’t matter. PM, text, or call me if you have some for sale!

06/12/2025

Just got in these fantastic mid-century, modern, hanging lamps. Chunky lucite lamps, very collectible!

05/24/2025

This weekend is opening musky fishing in Northern Wisconsin. Here at Poppin tags thrift store in Hayward, we have about 1000 lures to choose from. Plus, if you didn’t catch that musky today, we have some nice wooden musky plaques or coat racks for sale also! Stop on by and see us, we’re on Highway 27 south about four blocks away from the fishing Hall of Fame, in the Quonset hut.

12/25/2023

Merry Christmas from Poppin Tags Thrift Store

05/17/2023

What’s new at Poppin Tags Thrift Shop in Hayward Wisconsin? We have fishing lures, and lots of them, currently over 2000+ lures from bass fishing to Musky fishing. Just got these great roadside signs made up for my business. Signs were made by Darrel Vitcenda, local Hayward sign maker. I think he did a super job! Just thought I would share. Always buying and selling quality old and newer fishing lures.

09/20/2022

Got this new sign in my shop. Made it in 1 piece, neon still works!

04/05/2022

Just got some nice new things for the shop, summer is coming and trying to build up some better things in the shop. Here are some of my newest purchases. Some prepro beer boxes. 20 Ambassador reels. Nice 1960s Sears truck and trailer. Some old logging marking hammers. 1912 Barron County map. 300 comics. 3 old blasting machines. More coming in everyday day at Poppin tags thrift store in Hayward

07/10/2021

Went to look at an item off of Facebook yesterday, and it turned into a picking adventure. Here are some nice water skis I got yesterday, plus loads of other things