03/17/2026
Love it
In 1997, Eartha Kitt still did not know her own birthday. She had been a global star for four decades, and when students at Benedict College finally found her birth certificate, her father's name had been blacked out by the state.
For seventy years, Eartha Kitt did not know her own birthday.
She guessed at dates. She celebrated on January 26 for decades, a number pulled from nowhere, because no one had ever told her otherwise.
In 1997, she stood before a group of students at Benedict College in Columbia, South Carolina, and made a half-joking remark about never finding her birth certificate. Those students, at a historically Black college just miles from where she had been born, took the joke as a mission.
They searched the archives. They found the document she had spent a lifetime looking for.
When the court finally granted her access to the file months later, she opened it and saw what the state of South Carolina had decided she was allowed to know. Her birthday was January 17, 1927, and her birthplace was the small town of North, in Orangeburg County.
Where her father's name should have been, there was only a black mark. The name had been redacted by the state, because the man who fathered her was white and unmarried to her mother, and the law at the time made his identity unspeakable.
Her daughter, Kitt Shapiro, watched her cry.
Seventy years of wondering, and the answer the government gave her was an ink stain where a name should have been. That blacked-out line on a birth certificate tells you everything you need to know about the world Eartha Mae Keith was born into.
Her mother, Anna Mae, was fourteen years old when she gave birth. The father was a white man, likely connected to the cotton farm where Anna Mae worked, and Kitt herself would later say she believed her conception was the result of r**e.
In the Jim Crow South, the child's light skin made her a target from both directions. Black families in the area called her "yella gal," a term that carried no affection.
White society had no place for her at all.
When Anna Mae took up with a new man a few years later, he refused to keep the child. He would not raise a girl who looked like that, who reminded everyone of something no one wanted to name.
Anna Mae gave her daughter away. Eartha was about four years old.
The woman who took her in was called Mrs. Stern, and the arrangement was not kindness. It was labor disguised as guardianship.
The little girl was beaten for eating too much. Stern's own children abused and molested her.
When that household collapsed, Eartha was sent to a relative named Aunt Rosa. The pattern did not break.
By the time she was five, Eartha was working in cotton fields, the same fields where enslaved people had labored generations before her. She wore clothes sewn from potato sacks, and her feet were bare against the sharp stalks.
She would later recall the hunger in a BBC interview, describing how they survived on weeds pulled from the ground and wild grasses with small onions growing at the roots. When they could find things like that to eat, she said, they were all right.
When Eartha was about seven or eight, her mother died. The circumstances were never clearly explained to the child, and Kitt carried suspicions about what had really happened for the rest of her life.
Soon after, she was sent north to Harlem, to live with a woman named Mamie Kitt. For years, Eartha believed Mamie was a relative, perhaps an aunt.
Only later did she come to suspect that Mamie was actually her biological mother, and that Anna Mae had been raising someone else's child all along. No one ever confirmed the truth.
The adults in Eartha's life seemed to believe that explanations were not something owed to a child nobody had chosen.
Mamie's household brought piano and dance lessons, small mercies that hinted at another kind of life. But it also brought more beatings, more rejection, more of the same silence where love should have been.
Eartha attended Metropolitan Vocational High School, which would later become the famous High School of Performing Arts. A teacher there noticed something in the girl that years of violence had not managed to extinguish.
That teacher helped her stay in school, helped her find a foothold. But the relationship with Mamie deteriorated, and Eartha eventually left.
By fifteen, she was working factory jobs. By her mid-teens, she was homeless, sleeping in friends' apartments when she could, on rooftops when she could not, and on subway trains that ran through the night when there was nowhere else.
The subway was warm and anonymous. Millions of people passed through it every day without seeing her, and there was a strange comfort in that invisibility for a girl who had only ever been seen as a problem.
Then a friend dared her to audition for the Katherine Dunham Dance Company. Dunham's troupe was the first major Black modern dance company in the country, and it was no small thing to walk through those doors.
Eartha expected to be turned away. She got the job.
She was sixteen years old. For the first time in her life, someone had looked at her and seen not what she cost, not what she represented, but what she could do.
The company toured South America and Europe. The girl who had picked cotton barefoot in Orangeburg County found herself performing on stages in Paris.
She learned French, and then she learned to sing in ten languages, including Turkish and Hebrew. When the Dunham company returned to the United States, Eartha stayed behind in Paris, singing in nightclubs and becoming the kind of performer that people crossed cities to see.
Orson Welles found her in a Parisian nightclub and was so struck that he cast her as Helen of Troy in his 1950 stage adaptation of Faust. He called her the most exciting woman in the world, and the name stuck.
By 1952, she was on Broadway in the r***e New Faces of 1952, performing "Monotonous" in a way that made critics forget the word had ever meant anything dull. Her recordings of "C'est Si Bon," "I Want to Be Evil," and the now-immortal "Santa Baby" made her one of the most recognizable voices in American popular music.
She acted opposite Nat King Cole in St. Louis Blues and alongside Sidney Poitier in Anna Lucasta. She earned Tony and Grammy nominations.
In 1967, when the producers of the television series Batman needed to replace Julie Newmar as Catwoman for the show's third and final season, they called Eartha Kitt. She brought to the role a danger and elegance that redefined the character entirely, purring her way into a generation's memory.
Then, on January 18, 1968, she told the truth to the wrong people in the wrong room.
Lady Bird Johnson had invited fifty women to the White House for a "Women Doers Luncheon," a carefully staged event designed to discuss juvenile delinquency and bolster the Johnson administration's domestic agenda. Kitt had been invited because of her work with a D.C. youth organization called Rebels with a Cause, and she was one of only seven Black women among the forty-one guests.
One by one, the women at the luncheon offered polite remarks about beautifying highways and planting flowers in disadvantaged neighborhoods. Kitt sat with her hand raised, waiting.
When Mrs. Johnson finally called on her, Kitt did not talk about flower pots on the windowsills of poverty. She talked about mothers watching their sons get drafted into a war they did not understand.
She looked directly at the First Lady and said that American youth were rebelling because they could not get to her, and they could not get to the President, and so they rebelled in the only spaces left to them.
The room went silent. The narrative that emerged was simple and damaging: Eartha Kitt made the First Lady cry.
After the luncheon, the White House did not arrange a car to take her back to her hotel, even though a limousine had brought her there. She caught a cab, and on the radio during the ride, reporters were already telling the story of what she had done.
Within days, the Central Intelligence Agency compiled a dossier on her, drawing on data they had been collecting since 1956. The report described her as having a "very nasty disposition" and labeled her a "sadistic nymphomaniac."
It noted her connection to Martin Luther King Jr.'s civil rights efforts as if that were evidence of subversion. A woman seated at her table had whispered to thank her, saying most women in the room agreed with her but could not speak because their husbands worked for the President.
The blacklist was swift and thorough. Nightclubs canceled her engagements, her talent agency dropped her contract, and television companies were reportedly told that the President did not want to see "that woman" anywhere.
For nearly a decade, the most exciting woman in the world could not find work in her own country.
She performed in Europe instead, in bars and small venues across the continent. She never stopped working, but the stages got smaller and the distances from home got longer.
She would later say that her time abroad opened her eyes to how deeply racism was woven into American life in ways she had not fully understood before. She never apologized for what she said at the White House.
In 1975, New York Times reporter Seymour Hersh published a story revealing the existence of the CIA dossier. The exposure of the surveillance helped shift public sympathy back toward Kitt.
In 1978, President Jimmy Carter invited her to the White House, the same building that had tried to erase her a decade earlier. That same year, she returned to Broadway in the musical Timbuktu!, earning a Tony Award nomination.
The comeback was real but incomplete. Her career never fully recovered the momentum it had before January 18, 1968.
She kept performing, kept recording, kept acting. She appeared in Boomerang and Harriet the Spy, and her 1996 album Back in Business earned a Grammy nomination.
She became the voice of Yzma in Disney's The Emperor's New Groove, introducing herself to a generation of children who had no idea they were listening to a woman who once slept on subway grates. She won two Daytime Emmy Awards.
She became a spokesperson for UNICEF on behalf of abused children, a cause that needed no explanation from her. She also became an advocate for LGBT rights, speaking openly about solidarity with communities that understood rejection.
She once said that they were all rejected people who knew what it was to be refused, to be oppressed and depressed and accused, and that she was very familiar with that feeling.
In her private life, she married real estate executive William McDonald in 1960. Their daughter, Kitt Shapiro, was born the following year, and the marriage ended in 1964.
Shapiro would later write a memoir about growing up as the daughter of a woman who could seduce an entire audience but still carried the wounds of being the little girl nobody wanted. Kitt was a devoted mother, perhaps because she understood more than most what it meant to grow up without one.
She lived for years on a sprawling farm in a converted barn in New Milford, Connecticut, far from the cotton fields and the subway trains and the White House dining room. She kept a garden and raised her daughter.
And she never stopped wondering about the name that had been blacked out on her birth certificate.
Her daughter tried to help, hiring a lawyer and petitioning the court to unseal the records. It took six or seven months, and when the files were finally opened, Eartha was allowed to look at them for only fifteen minutes.
The father's name was still gone. Blacked out, even in the twenty-first century, even for a seventy-one-year-old woman who had performed in 108 countries and been surveilled by her own government.
Eartha Kitt died on Christmas Day, 2008, at her home in Weston, Connecticut. She was eighty-one years old, and the cause was colon cancer.
In 2016, South Carolina declared January 17 as Eartha Kitt Day. In 2022, the state enshrined the date into law.
The same state that had blacked out her father's name now claimed her as its own.
Her daughter once shared something Eartha told her near the end. She always said to make sure that what she had done did not die with her.
Not the songs or the roles, because those would live on. She meant who she was as a person, as a mother, and what she stood for.
Somewhere in a government archive, there is still a birth certificate with a line of black ink where a man's name should be. And somewhere in the memory of everyone who ever heard that voice, low and knowing and threaded with survival, there is a woman who made herself whole out of everything the world refused to give her.
The ink could cover a name. It could not cover her.
I put a lot of effort into researching and sharing stories that matter. If you’d like to support the work, here’s the link:
https://ko-fi.com/blackhistorystories
Every coffee helps me keep creating.
