Simply Sugar Boutique

Simply Sugar Boutique Sugary treats made simply sweet 🫶🏻
Handcrafted sweet treats & desserts, always boutique.

Custom desserts, cake pops & dipped treats.
📍 Greenwood, IN
By appointment only -

08/14/2026

🎃✨ ONLY 3 AVAILABLE FRIDAY EVENING! ✨🎃I’m trying something NEW! 🍪💕Confetti Sugar Cookie Sandwiches — two soft, buttery c...
08/14/2026

🎃✨ ONLY 3 AVAILABLE FRIDAY EVENING! ✨🎃

I’m trying something NEW! 🍪💕

Confetti Sugar Cookie Sandwiches — two soft, buttery confetti sugar cookies filled with buttercream and covered in colorful sprinkles! 🌈

Each one is a BIG—7 oz and individually wrapped in cute Halloween paper, then sealed to keep it fresh.

🎃 $7 each — only 3 available!

Who wants one?! 👀🍪

Golden Oreo crumble, Strawberry 🍓 crunch and Chocolate 🍫 cake Oreo added to the fridge for tomorrow!
08/14/2026

Golden Oreo crumble, Strawberry 🍓 crunch and Chocolate 🍫 cake Oreo added to the fridge for tomorrow!

08/12/2026

kpopdemonhuntercake

✨ PSA from your local cake lady 😂🎂Ribbons, edible images, fancy frames, sprinkles, toppers… YES, they cost extra! 😜Becau...
08/12/2026

✨ PSA from your local cake lady 😂🎂

Ribbons, edible images, fancy frames, sprinkles, toppers… YES, they cost extra! 😜

Because “plain cake” and BIRTHDAY CAKE are two very different things! 😂

Birthdays only come once a year—so let’s splurge make that treat feel SPECIAL! 🎀✨

You’re not just paying for the ribbon… you’re paying for the WOW! 💕

Can’t wait to add bows 🎀 to these K-Pop Demon Hunter pops!
08/12/2026

Can’t wait to add bows 🎀 to these K-Pop Demon Hunter pops!

I L❤️VE baking for my FAMILYEvery few months when I get to bake for them , it’s the best! They let me create new flavors...
08/11/2026

I L❤️VE baking for my FAMILY

Every few months when I get to bake for them , it’s the best! They let me create new flavors, and trust me to design however I want! No stress, just baking enjoyment. 🥰

This is when I enjoy baking the most. Give me a flavor, color scheme and theme, let me do the rest!

It’s never fun when my baking freedom is taken away and I’m given strict creation rules or have to design it “just like this”.

You’re aware I can’t “copy” someone’s work exact right? It’s wrong first of all, and secondly I’m not a copy machine. And lastly…honestly why would you want to be the same? Don’t you want your treats to be special? Because, I do!??!

So…I HAD to try someone else’s cake pops. 🤷🏻‍♀️You know…know your competition. 😂🔎White cake pop is NOT MINE. And y’all…M...
08/11/2026

So…I HAD to try someone else’s cake pops. 🤷🏻‍♀️
You know…know your competition. 😂🔎
White cake pop is NOT MINE.

And y’all…MY OPINION ONLY…👀

1️⃣ Overall: AWFUL. 🤣
2️⃣ It was supposed to be “Oreo.” The only Oreo I found was the tiny amount of crumble on the outside.
3️⃣ Inside? Plain chocolate cake…and it had a weird taste. 😬
4️⃣ The white chocolate coating? Also…weird taste.
5️⃣ Final score: 3/10. Would NOT buy again.
6️⃣ Price: $2.89 — officially the cheapest cake pop I’ve ever bought.

Was it worth the $2.89? Probably not. 😂
But would I do it again occasionally? ABSOLUTELY.

Because when you make something for people, you need to know what’s out there. And sometimes you need a little reminder of WHY you do things the way you do. 😉

So yes…I wasted $2.89.
But I also walked away saying:

“Yep. Mine are worth every penny.” 💅🏼🍰🎀

Theirs vs mine…

Address

1479 Pencross Lane
Greenwood, IN
46143

Telephone

+13172136608

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Simply Sugar Boutique posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Simply Sugar Boutique:

Shortcuts

Share