CNY Card Co-Op

CNY Card Co-Op CNY Card Co-Op is a family owned shop rooted in Otsego County, NY. We see every card as a snapshot, preserving history while embracing the thrill of the hunt.

From rare finds to hidden gems, collecting connects people and turns moments into memories

03/17/2026

Hey all! Had to reschedule again as I will be getting my wisdom teeth removed on Friday. Hoping I'll be good for the 24th.

How cool are these???
03/11/2026

How cool are these???

Budweiser 🤝 Baseball Season.

Hey all!!! Scheduling a show for St. Patricks day for Basketball only!
03/11/2026

Hey all!!! Scheduling a show for St. Patricks day for Basketball only!

Starting in 7 mins!!!!
03/11/2026

Starting in 7 mins!!!!

03/10/2026

Due to my (Gwen) children (3 & 1) not exactly having a good night...we have to reschedule the show for tomorrow HOPEFULLY at 9pm. Daylight savings time hasn't been kind to them.

Have a good night everyone.

Technology issues FINALLY figured out. Will be going live tonight around 845pm! Hope to see you all there!
03/09/2026

Technology issues FINALLY figured out. Will be going live tonight around 845pm! Hope to see you all there!

Hey CNY! Meet the Crew Behind CNY Card Co-Op! ⚾🏈🏀CNY Card Co-Op isn’t some card collector/seller...it’s just our family ...
03/09/2026

Hey CNY! Meet the Crew Behind CNY Card Co-Op! ⚾🏈🏀

CNY Card Co-Op isn’t some card collector/seller...it’s just our family bringing our love of sports, collecting, and community together right here in Central New York.

First up is John Davis Sr. (Dad) is a NYS Class D Baseball Hall of Famer out of Binghamton, NY. Baseball is in his blood, and if there’s a conversation about sports history, stats, or the hobby…he’s probably already in it.

Then there’s Shaundra Davis (Mom) is a local science teacher who’s honestly one of the best in the profession. She keeps us all thinking, learning, and occasionally reminds us to keep things organized when the card piles start getting a little too CNY basement-style.

John Davis Jr. is the hustle of the crew. A former track star at our high school, he brings that same drive and determination to everything he does. If there’s a job to get done, sorting cards, setting up cards for auctions, or helping collectors he’s all in.

And then there’s Gwen McAuliffe and her husband Nathaniel McAuliffe. Gwen is the stay-at-home mom powerhouse who helps keep the wheels turning behind the scenes while helping grow the community side of the Co-Op.

Together we created CNY Card Co-Op...a place for collectors to buy, sell, trade, and enjoy the hobby without the nonsense. Just good people, good cards, and a little bit of that classic CNY hospitality.

Whether you're chasing rookies, hunting slabs, or just love the thrill of the auction…

Welcome to the Co-Op. Grab a seat, you’re family here. 🧡📦

03/06/2026

✨ Whatnot Show Rules – Please Read Before Bidding ✨

Thank you so much for being here and supporting my small business! Please review the show rules before bidding:

📦 Shipping
- Shipping is handled directly through Whatnot.
- Please ensure your address is correct before purchasing.
- Once packages are dropped off, I am not responsible for carrier delays, damage, or lost packages, but I will help however I can if issues arise.

💎 All Sales Final
- All items are sold as-is.
-I do my best to show and describe items accurately during the live.
-No cancellations, refunds, or buyer’s remorse.

⏳ Payment
Payment is processed automatically through Whatnot at the end of the show.
If payment fails, the item may be relisted or offered to the next bidder.

🔮 Mystery / Blind Items
Any mystery or blind items are part of the fun and cannot be exchanged.
Please bid knowing you may receive any item within that category.

💬 Respectful Community
- Be kind and respectful to everyone in the chat.
- Harassment, negativity, or drama will not be tolerated and may result in removal from the show.
📹 Live Claim Awareness
Bids are binding.
Please bid responsibly.

✨ Most importantly...have fun! I appreciate every single one of you being here and supporting my shop. ✨

📣 Whatnot Show Lineup – Here’s How Tonight Will Go!

Just a quick rundown so everyone knows what to expect during the show 👇

⚾ Round 1 – Baseball Cards
We’ll be starting things off with $2 starts on a variety of baseball cards. Great chance to grab some deals and add to your collection.

🏈 Round 2 – Football Cards
Next up we’ll move into football cards, again starting at $2
🏀 Round 3 – Basketball Cards
After football we’ll jump into basketball cards, still running those $2 starts.

💎 Higher-End Cards
Once we finish the main rounds, we’ll start showing some of the more valuable / higher-end cards for those looking for bigger hits.

⚡ Pokémon Time
To wrap things up we’ll check out:
Pokémon cards
Pokémon slabs

There should be a little something for everyone tonight whether you're collecting, hunting deals, or chasing slabs.

🔥 $2 starts early — so don’t miss it!

03/06/2026

Getting everything set up and ready for tonight's WhatNot show!

03/06/2026

✨ Reminder! WhatNot Live Show Tomorrow Night! ✨

Just a quick reminder that we’ll be going LIVE on WhatNot tomorrow night at 8:30 PM EST! 🛍️

We’ll have some awesome items up for grabs, good vibes, and plenty of fun hanging out with everyone during the show. Whether you’re looking to snag something special or just want to pop in and say hi, we’d love to see you there!

Set your reminder, grab a drink, and come join us!

📅 Tomorrow
⏰ 8:30 PM EST
📍 WhatNot Live

See you there! 💫

Getting ready! Only one more week until our first show! Website is almost done and we can't wait to get everything out t...
02/27/2026

Getting ready! Only one more week until our first show! Website is almost done and we can't wait to get everything out to you guys!

Address

N/A
Edmeston, NY
13335

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when CNY Card Co-Op posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Share