Smitty's Cards and Coins

Smitty's Cards and Coins We have a diverse selection of coins, currency, gaming packs and other collectibles. We buy and sell and offer free appraisals so stop by and check us out.

Located at the northern tip of Canandaigua Lake in upstate New York, we offer a chance to browse our diverse selection of coins, paper money, and other collectibles. We welcome the opportunity to buy, sell or trade coins and gold and we provide free appraisals with no string attached or obligation to sell. We pay the highest prices and pride ourselves in being fair, honest, and an asset to our com

munity. Stop by and check us out! We also have regular Magic the Gathering (MTG) card tournaments - we buy and sell packs, booster boxes, and singles. Lots to look at - a full case of singles, many binders, and boxes and boxes of the last few sets!

01/14/2026

We will be closing early on Saturday, January 17, closing at 3:30 PM, because the Buffalo Bills playoff game. please message or call with any questions… It’s only 30 minutes earlier than usual, for our winter hours, but just a heads up. Go bills!

07/23/2025

Just as a reminder, we’re closed Saturday, July 26, 2025 - all day. Everyone on the team has something going on! It should be the only Saturday we’re closed all summer.  we are open regular hours the Friday before and also regular hours the Monday following. 

11/19/2022

The store is closing today (Saturday) @ 3:30 pm - November 19,2022
Open Wednesday this week regular hours
Closed Thursday and Friday
Regular hours back starting next Saturday (after Thanksgiving)

11/25/2021
Special purchase rates for December 2021!
11/25/2021

Special purchase rates for December 2021!

05/30/2021

One other item.. We are mask optimal if you have had your shots aren't aren't showing any signs of the flu. We will NOT be asking - and yes, you are welcome to wear a mask if you would like - we are using the honor system! Also, we are restarting Magic the Gathering events - please see our "Smitty's Gaming Regulars" group for more info and the schedule. We all hope the numbers continue to improve!

05/30/2021

Happy Summer 2021 everyone! We have added some Morgan Dollars (certified and raw) - and Wheat Penny bags and rolls are bacl. Hope to you see you all soon - open every Saturday until Mid July - (closed on July 17th) - then open every Saturday after that!

10/04/2020

We are open:
Saturdays from 10am-4pm,
Mondays from 10am-1:30pm Wednesdays from 10am-1:30pm
Fridays from 10am-1:30pm

Masks are required. Max of 6 customers in-store, and 15-minute limit please!

Please be like the tyrannosaurus rex today - No touching, just ask for help! We can get your the coin and card binders you want to look at.

Thank you for your patience and understanding!

Team Smitty’s

Address

80 S Main Street
Canandaigua, NY
14424

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 3pm
Wednesday 10am - 3pm
Thursday 10am - 3pm
Friday 10am - 3pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm

Telephone

+15853943650

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Smitty's Cards and Coins posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Smitty's Cards and Coins:

Shortcuts

Share

Category