The Toys Time Forgot

The Toys Time Forgot For over 30 years we have sold vintage toys and comic books spanning the 1950's to the present day. Then he was laid-off. What else?
(494)

Once upon a time, Dan Hare planned to work a few years as an engineer, build up a savings, then open a vintage toy store when he retired. He completed his degree in engineering and, for a time, it seemed everything was going according to plan. He decided to revise the plan and put his family's future in his own hands. He opened an antique toy and collectibles store called The Toys Time Forgot. The

Toys Time Forgot began in 1991 as a 500 square foot storefront offering vintage toys and non-sport trading cards. At 4300 square feet today, the store has grown to be one of the largest vintage toy stores in the Northeast United States. The store's product offering expanded as the floor space grew. Comic books, newer collectible toys such as Transformers, G.I. Joe, one of the largest Star Wars collections in Ohio now accompany the vintage toys and non-sport cards. The store has so many super-hero, horror, cartoon, TV and movie action figures they cover the walls and hang in long rows from the ceiling! Over 100 statues, western toys, vintage sports games, bobble heads, Pop Heroes, and Magic the Gathering and Yu-Gi-Oh gaming cards. But don't think that The Toys Time Forgot is just another comic book shop. True vintage toys and collectibles still dominate the shelf space. We have tin wind-ups, battery ops, over 100 board games, figures and dolls from the 1930's through the 1970's, and now into the 80's. Time was, Dan traveled to yard sales, auctions and flea markets to find the lost treasures and put them on sale in the store. Today, people bring collections from all over to his front door every day of the week. Customers travel from around the world to Canal Fulton, Ohio, a small town near Akron, Canton, and Cleveland in Northeast Ohio, where they find truly original, vintage and antique toys. The Toys Time Forgot is located in Canal Fulton's newly renovated historic post office building. The floor space is dedicated to the greatest variety of new and classic toys and collectibles you are likely to find under one roof. "The variety and sheer number of toys I have is impressive. However, my success comes from quality customer service. As much as that sounds like a cliché, it is true. Customers come back to our store because we treat people with genuine respect. As a buyer I am fair, and as a seller I am honest. But most of all I make collecting antique toys fun!"

Dan Hare, Proprietor

08/07/2026

1975 Tree Tots Family Treehouse by Kenner and made in Cincinnati, Ohio!

08/06/2026

"These are the figures you're looking!" 🧓🤚

08/05/2026

Nightmare fuel anyone? 🤡

His vacation has ended and he is back to his normal mischievous ways! Find Creepy in the store to save 20% off your purc...
08/05/2026

His vacation has ended and he is back to his normal mischievous ways! Find Creepy in the store to save 20% off your purchase!

08/04/2026

The countdown is on! 🎉

Join us Saturday, August 8 from 11 AM–4 PM for a celebration of art, creativity, and community in Historic Downtown Canal Fulton.

Whether you’re an art enthusiast, a family looking for a fun day out, or simply want to explore downtown, there’s something for everyone!

✨ Artist & Maker Marketplace
📚 Local Authors
🎶 Live Performances
🛶 Cardboard Boat Regatta
🎮 Cleveland Video Game Symphony
🍧 Kona Ice + Food Trucks
🎨 Paint & Sip at The Barrel Room
🧒 Kids Zone
💙 Sensory Zone

Admission is FREE, family-friendly, and everyone is welcome!

Who are you bringing with you?

08/04/2026

New Toy Tuesday!

Mark stopped in with his family and took advantage of the final day of our Christmas in July sale! He was excited to to ...
08/01/2026

Mark stopped in with his family and took advantage of the final day of our Christmas in July sale! He was excited to to snag the 1978 Super Joe Terron by Hasbro complete in the box and works!

08/01/2026

1954 Blockhead game by Blockhead Inc. Made in Akron Ohio!

Address

137 Cherry Street E
Canal Fulton, OH
44614

Opening Hours

Tuesday 11am - 7pm
Wednesday 11am - 7pm
Thursday 11am - 7pm
Friday 11am - 7pm
Saturday 10am - 7pm

Telephone

+13308541700

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Toys Time Forgot posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Toys Time Forgot:

Shortcuts

Share

Category