Bethany Sports Cards Plus

05/28/2026

Effective Immediately!
We will not be taking any PSA submissions for the next two weeks. This is so we can evaluate our options for customers as PSA has paused all Value submissions until furthur notice. We support PSA & do believe this will get better before the end of the year. For all submissions already submitted your cards are all in process and nothing has been halted. SGC submissions are still live & we are still taking those. We will look into BGS as well for customers. For any questions contact Max or the shop.

PSA is temporarily pausing Value, Value Bulk, Value Plus, and Value Max submissions starting June 2, 2026, to reduce a 10M-card backlog. Here's what's changing.

05/28/2026

🏀 NEW RELEASE DROP! 🏀
The highly anticipated 2025-26 Topps Signature Class Basketball is officially arriving at Bethany Sports Cards Plus!

Featuring stunning designs, the game's biggest stars like Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, and 2 Autographs per box, this is a release you do not want to miss. Whether you're chasing top rookies or elite veterans, this set is packed with massive hits.

⚠️ Important Details:
📅 Release Date: Wednesday, May 28, 2026
📍 Availability: In-Store Only!
Stop by the shop on release day to grab your boxes before they sell out. See you there! 🙌

05/26/2026

Something massive is dropping at the beach. 🌊🔥

Get ready, collectors. We’ve been working on a massive project behind the scenes, and the logo says it all. ML HITS is coming soon to Bethany Sports Cards Plus.

We aren't giving away the details just yet, but if you love high-end chasing and guaranteed quality, you'll want to turn your post notifications ON for this one.

Stay tuned. The game is about to change. 🤫👀

05/25/2026

We will be closing the store at 6PM today. Thank you all for a great memorial weekend!!!

05/25/2026

Wishing you a solemn and reflective Memorial Day from Bethany Sports Cards Plus. Today, we honor and remember those who made the ultimate sacrifice for our country. Thank you for your service.

05/22/2026

Discover the thrilling world of Pokemon Mega Evolution Chaos Rising at Bethany Sports Cards Plus! Unleash the power of legendary Pokemon with this exciting expansion. Visit our store today to add these coveted cards to your collection and elevate your gameplay. Don't miss out on this opportunity for epic battles and strategic victories!

05/21/2026

It’s official—Shai Gilgeous-Alexander is your back-to-back 2026 NBA MVP! 🏆🔥

For basketball collectors, this means the Topps MVP Buyback Program is officially locked in for SGA. If you’ve been pulling or holding his Topps Chrome base cards, inserts, or parallels, they just turned into hobby shop credit! 💰

Want to know exactly how the buyback works, which cards qualify, and how you can trade them in with us? We’ve put together a complete collector's guide to break down all the details.

👉 Read the full guide on our blog: https://bit.ly/4dCdqxb

05/20/2026

Join us for the Memorial Day Weekend at Bethany Sports Cards Plus! We'll be open from 8am to 8pm on May 22-25, offering a wide selection of sports cards, Pokemon, and memorabilia. We look forward to welcoming you!

05/19/2026

Memorial Day weekend starts the heat, and we are kicking off summer with May’s biggest releases! 🇺🇸🔥

If you are hunting for the hottest drops in sports cards and collectibles, Bethany Sports Cards Plus is your ultimate destination this weekend. Here is what hits our shelves IN-STORE ONLY:

🏒 Upper Deck SPx Hockey The chase is officially on! Stop in to hunt for massive hits, including:

Connor Bedard Rookie Autographs
MacKinnon Memorabilia
Limited "Break the Mold" inserts
🐉 Pokémon: Chaos Rising Unleash the power of Mega Evolutions! We have brand-new Elite Trainer Boxes and Booster Packs ready for your collection. Battle for the ultimate power!

👕 Looking for gear? We also have over 1,000+ jerseys in stock with all sizes available for the whole family!

Stop by and see us this weekend to grab these limited in-store releases before they fly off the shelves. We are open year-round with a friendly, professional crew and fair prices.

📍 123 Garfield Pkwy, Unit 7, Bethany Beach, DE
📞 (302) 537-6330
🌐 https://BethanySportsCardsPlus.com

ConnorBedard

05/18/2026

The 2026 NBA Conference Finals kick off tonight, and the basketball card market is absolutely on fire! 🏀🔥

With massive star-studded matchups on deck, playoff performances are about to drive card values to a whole new level:

In the West: Victor Wembanyama and the Spurs take on SGA's Thunder.
In the East: Jalen Brunson and the Knicks go head-to-head with the Cavs.
Whether you are looking to buy the dip, sell the hype, or hold onto your cornerstone pieces, you need a strategy. We just dropped our official 2026 Conference Finals Card Guide to help you navigate the market right now.

👉 Check out the blog for the full breakdown: https://bit.ly/4dCdqxb