05/14/2026
PSA Busters Myth #1: Perfect centering does NOT = PSA 10
Most collectors obsess over centering because it’s easy to see.
In reality, modern PSA grades are often decided by tiny surface or edge defects you only notice under angled light.
At first glance, this card looks like an easy PSA 10 candidate. The front centering is excellent, the autograph is bold and clean, and the patch window presents beautifully. That’s exactly why grades like this surprise collectors.
But once you start evaluating the card through PSA’s lens instead of the hobby’s “eye appeal” lens, the likely reasons for the PSA 8 become clearer.
The biggest issue is probably corner and edge wear — specifically on the back. Thick premium patch cards like Topps Definitive are notoriously difficult to keep pristine because the heavier stock and layered construction make the corners vulnerable straight out of the pack. Looking closely at the reverse, there appears to be subtle whitening and edge chipping along portions of the border, particularly near the corners. On ultra-thick cards, even small amounts of fraying or fiber exposure can immediately cap the grade.
Surface sensitivity is another likely factor. Chrome-style gloss and premium stock often pick up tiny scratches, pressure marks, or handling lines that scanners and listing photos struggle to capture. PSA grades surface defects aggressively, especially on high-end cards where expectations are higher.
This card is a perfect example of one of the biggest grading misconceptions:
Perfect centering does NOT guarantee a high grade.
Centering may get the card “in the conversation” for a 10, but surface, corners, and edges usually determine whether it actually gets there.