https://www.facebook.com/574333239107434/

Reynolds' Relics, Kearneysville, WV (2026)

06/03/2026

📬 HUGE TTM RETURN DAY AT REYNOLDS RELICS! 📬

We have an incredible mix of youth and legendary history hitting the mailbox today! From one of the brightest young stars in modern golf to an absolute icon of hockey history, today’s TTM returns did not disappoint.
Here is a look at what just arrived:

🏌️‍♂️ Gordon Sargent – The Future of Golf
First up, we got these three beautiful autographed cards back from Gordon Sargent! If you haven't been keeping up with him, he's the absolute real deal out of Vanderbilt. He made history as the first player ever to earn a PGA Tour card directly through the PGA Tour U Accelerated program, and his raw clubhead speed is just otherworldly.

These look sharp as can be, beautifully signed in black ink!

🇨🇦 Yvan Cournoyer – "The Roadrunner"
From the links to the ice, we have a massive mailday from Montreal Canadiens legend and Hockey Hall of Famer, Yvan Cournoyer! Ten Stanley Cups, a Conn Smythe Trophy, and a massive hero of the 1972 Summit Series for Team Canada—safe to say he's an absolute immortal of the game.

He signed these three vintage-style beauties for us in a stunning blue ink that absolutely pops off the cards.

06/01/2026

📬 REYNOLDS RELICS TTM RETURNS! 📬

The mailbox was absolutely loaded today with a couple of incredible multi-card returns! We are bridging two completely different eras of athletic greatness today—going from a gritty 1970s gridiron icon to a modern winter sports queen.

Steve Grogan (New England Patriots Legend)

We got the legendary Patriots signal-caller back, and his bold black signature looks incredible on these two vintage beauties:

1976 Topps Rookie Card – An absolute holy grail for the vintage football archive. Seeing his signature on that iconic rookie design is as good as it gets!

1982 Topps – A beautiful, clean look that perfectly captures his legendary 16-year run in New England.

Jamie Anderson (Snowboarding Royalty)

Talk about action sports gold! The most decorated woman in X Games history went above and beyond for our archive request:

Signed BOTH of her stunning 2026 Topps Chrome cards in a gorgeous, flowing blue ink. Her autograph style is seriously so cool—it looks like pure art!

Surprised us by including a beautiful handwritten note on cardboard that reads: "Thank you for the kind message ⚓ Sending you all love & good energy! xoxo Life is a gift. Jamie ☺"

A massive thank you to both Mr. Grogan and Jamie for being so incredibly gracious with the fans!

05/30/2026

Today’s TTM Return is "The Ignitor" himself! 🚨 Paul Molitor!

Absolutely thrilled to get these two pieces back from Hall of Famer Paul Molitor for the Reynolds Relics Archive.

First up is his 2022 Allen & Ginter Mini SP, featuring him in his iconic Blue Jays uniform from that legendary '93 World Series MVP run. A modern classic!

But the absolute jewel of this return is the '81 Topps Milwaukee Brewers Team Card. This card already has the autograph of pitcher Mike Caldwell. Today, Paul added his beautiful signature right next to Caldwell’s, completing the dual-signed team relic and perfectly capturing that classic "Harvey's Wallbangers" era.

Molitor is a true class act and a legendary figure in both Milwaukee and Toronto history. This makes a great addition to our preservation efforts.

05/26/2026

📬 REYNOLDS RELICS TTM RETURN! 📬

The mailbox was absolutely loaded today with a couple of incredible returns! We went from a fiery baseball legend to one of the best mascots in the game.

1. "Sweet Lou" Piniella
We got the legendary Lou Piniella back, and he looks amazing on these two completely different styles:

2023 Allen & Ginter Mini – A super clean, classic look that fits his pinstripe days perfectly.

1972 Topps "Boyhood Photos of the Stars" – This one is an absolute beauty for the vintage project. Love seeing the bold blue ink on that classic '72 design!

2. Fredbird (St. Louis Cardinals Mascot)
Talk about mascot mail gold! We sent off to everyone's favorite bird in St. Louis, and he went above and beyond:

Signed his 2026 Topps flagship card in a bold black Sharpie.

Completely surprised us by throwing in FOUR signed copies of his 2017 Topps All-Star Game card!

Thanks to both Lou and the Fredbird team for being so gracious with the fans!

05/19/2026

📬 DOUBLE MAIL-DAY: Olympic Gold & Met-Life Magic! 📬

The mailbox brought a massive contrast in eras today, and it is absolute fire! We just pulled in two incredible, unique pieces from two complete masters of their sports: modern Olympic gold medalist Alex Ferreira and the legendary Darryl Strawberry!

Check out how beautifully these turned out:

🏂 Alex Ferreira — 2026 Topps Chrome Winter Olympics Relic

Fresh off capturing his spectacular Olympic Gold Medal in Milano Cortina, the halfpipe king signed this beautiful Topps Chrome memorabilia card. He signed it with a thick, bold black sharpie right across the front. Look closely at the left side—he even threw in a sketch of a winter beanie/goggle character! That is an incredible, personalized touch from the man behind "Hotdog Hans." Plus, the bonus stickers he threw in are an awesome addition to the mailday!

🍎 Darryl Strawberry — 2025 Topps Allen & Ginter Mini (A&G Back)

"The Straw" looks absolutely iconic on this 2025 Allen & Ginter mini. Getting minis signed TTM can be tough because of the limited real estate, but Strawberry absolutely nailed it with a perfect, vibrant blue ink signature right across his chest. Seeing that classic 1980s Mets uniform paired with a crisp, on-card auto in the vintage A&G frame is pure hobby perfection.

An Olympic champion and a 4-time World Series champion in the exact same mailday—it doesn't get much better than this.

05/18/2026

📬 TTM RETURN: Hall of Famer Jim "Kitty" Kaat! 📬

The mailbox was extra friendly today! We just got back a beautiful 3-for-3 TTM return from legendary left-hander and 2022 Hall of Fame inductee, Jim Kaat!

"Kitty" signed all three of these vintage beauties in a gorgeous, bold blue sharpie that absolutely pops off the cardboard.
Here’s the breakdown of today’s mailday additions:

1961 Topps #63: An awesome early-career look at Kaat in the classic high-collar Twins uniform. That vintage yellow cartoon corner insert looks incredible signed.

1963 Fleer #22: A tough, beautifully centered short-print era classic. Seeing that classic "Twins" script paired with a clean on-card auto is pure hobby magic.

1971 Topps #245: You all know how brutal those black borders are on '71 Topps condition-wise, but that blue ink looks absolutely phenomenal contrasting against the dark design.

25 seasons, 283 wins, and 16 consecutive Gold Gloves—Jim Kaat is an absolute legend of the game and remains one of the most gracious signers for the fans. These are headed straight into the personal collection archive!

05/16/2026

The mailday delivery came from the South Side today! 📬⚾️

Check out this Through-The-Mail return from everyone’s favorite fuzzy green dude—Southpaw, the legendary mascot of the Chicago White Sox! 🧦🟢

He signed this crisp 2026 Topps Celebration Mascots card beautifully. True to his name, the Mascot Hall of Famer is a strict lefty, and that signature looks sharp right across the pinstripes! ✍️🔥

Mascot TTMs are some of the most fun, unique additions you can make to a collection, and Southpaw is always an absolute class act with the fans.

05/15/2026

🏆 MASSIVE TTM FRIDAY at Reynolds Relics! 🏆

The mailbox was absolutely packed today with some heavy hitters for the family archive. From Super Bowl legends to Olympic Gold Medalists, today was a reminder of why we love the TTM hobby!

Today’s Returns:
🔴 Mr. Red (Cincinnati Reds): Signed on a beautiful 2026 Topps card! But the real highlight was the incredibly classy handwritten note from the Reds organization. "Reds Country" truly is special! 🇺🇸

🏴‍☠️ Brad Johnson: The Super Bowl ###VII champ signed this 2002 Pacific Heads Up in a bold blue sharpie, including the "SB 37 Champ" inscription! A total pro and a legendary signer.

🏒 Tessa Janecke: Fresh off the 2026 Olympics, the Team USA star signed her 2026 Topps Chrome card. She is the future of the game, and this is a huge addition to our hockey archive.

⛳ Jasmine Koo: A massive thank you to Jasmine for her grace! I accidentally sent two different requests, and she was kind enough to sign and return both. We ended up with a gorgeous trio: 2026 Upper Deck Young Guns, 2026 UD Retro, and the 2026 UD Season Highlights Debut.

Four legends, one mailbox, and a lot of hobby joy.

05/12/2026

📬 TTM Return: A Hockey Legend!

We just got these back from the legendary Mark Howe. It is an honor to add some ink from a Hockey Hall of Famer and a Philadelphia Flyers icon to the collection.

1988 Topps Mark Howe (x2)
1989 Topps Mark Howe

Howe wasn't just "Gordie's son"—he was one of the most dominant two-way defensemen to ever hit the ice. He remains the Flyers' all-time leading scorer among defensemen and a true class act for fans of the hobby.

05/11/2026

The "Sweet Swingin'" legend himself, Hall of Famer Billy Williams, just sent back some absolute heat. There is something special about seeing that iconic blue ink flow across the vintage cardboard of the 60s and 70s. Billy’s signature is still as smooth as his legendary left-handed swing.

Check out this trio of Cubs history:

1963 Topps #353: A beautiful early-career look at Billy coming off his Rookie of the Year campaign.

1965 Topps #220: That classic "Cubs" banner design looks even better with a clean HOF autograph.

1971 Topps #350: The notorious black borders are hard to find in good shape, and this one looks sharp with the blue signature popping against that dark frame.

Billy remains one of the most consistent and classiest signers in the hobby. These are headed straight for the personal collection for a bit before we figure out our next PSA bulk submission!

Reynolds' Relics

06/03/2026

06/01/2026

05/30/2026

05/26/2026

05/19/2026

05/18/2026

05/16/2026

05/15/2026

05/12/2026

05/11/2026

Address

Website

Alerts

Contact The Business

Shortcuts

Share

Category